PDA Cover Competition Group 21

[Paul Clement]

[Dirk Gently]

Instruments of Darkness for not being a photo montage.

[Paul Clement]

World Game looks quite good and just shades Instruments of Darkness for me.

[Larry]

Wages of Sin, for me.

[Andrew Curnow]

As Tim says, it's laudable that Instruments of Darkness is artwork rather than photoshopping, but unfortunately it's a not very inspiring piece of artwork. Wages of Sin is dreadful, with no sense of construction, and really does look as if the faces were just plonked anywhere (and the lack of contrast doesn't even make them stand out in anyway). So although it's by no means a seamless bit of work, I'm going for World Game, which is a clever idea and quite a nice end-product.

[SiHart]

Far be it from me to disagree with Andrew!

Si xx

[Dave Tudor]

A poor group, but at least Instruments Of Darkness looks quite nice, despite its lack of 'Who' elements.

[Stuart Wallis]

Largely because there's only one photo, and is mainly artwork, World Game works best.

[Pip Madeley]

Interesting trio of covers - first off, The Wages Of Sin is just bobbins. Four images scattered in mist, sigh. Instruments Of Darkness is nice artwork, but it's not my cup of tea. Like Andrew, I think World Game is a clever concept and nicely realised (Troughton looks very comical, as ever!)