Last Regeneration Standing (NEGATIVE VOTING!)

[Antony Cox]

Hartnell to Troughton - 6
Pertwee to T Baker - 5
T Baker to Davison - 8
Davison to c Baker - 7
McCoy to McGann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 3

[Ralph]

I'm even more confused now!

[Antony Cox]

Sorry - I wasn't paying attention!

Hartnell to Troughton - 6
Pertwee to T Baker - 6
T Baker to Davison - 8
Davison to c Baker - 7
McCoy to McGann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 3

[Ralph]

Si changed several and highlighted none so it's anybody's guess - I suggest we start to where we were before he posted and get his correct vote later.
If we go back to Paul's vote and add your vote to Pertwee/Baker then:

Hartnell to Troughton - 6
Pertwee to T Baker - 8
T Baker to Davison - 7
Davison to C Baker - 8
McCoy to McGann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 6
Jacobi to Simm - 3

so waiting on what Si actually wanted! as you can see the results are quite different!

[Dirk Gently]

I don't know what the hell is going on, I'll just copy the last list & go from there. Imagine that, hitting reply & then copying the last post, what will I think of next.

Hartnell to Troughton - 6
Pertwee to T Baker - 8
T Baker to Davison - 7
Davison to C Baker - 8
McCoy to McGann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 6
Jacobi to Simm - 2

[Larry]

Hartnell to Troughton - 6
Pertwee to T Baker - 8
T Baker to Davison - 8
Davison to C Baker - 8
McCoy to McGann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 6
Jacobi to Simm - 2

[Antony Cox]

If we go back to Paul's vote and add your vote to Pertwee/Baker then:

But I didn't add one to Pertwee/Baker, Ralph - I deducted one! You can't blindly assume everyone's going to add a vote to it!

So purely on the Pertwee/Baker status, the line-up should now be:

Hartnell to Troughton - 6
Pertwee to T Baker - 6
T Baker to Davison - 7
Davison to C Baker - 8
McCoy to McGann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 6
Jacobi to Simm - 3

[Dirk Gently]

So if Ant is removing one from Pertwee/Baker then it should look like this then.

Hartnell to Troughton - 6
Pertwee to T Baker - 6
T Baker to Davison - 8
Davison to C Baker - 8
McCoy to McGann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 6
Jacobi to Simm - 2

OK?

[Antony Cox]

OK?

Only if you assume that Si was adding to Baker/Davison rather than deducting one from Ecclestone/Tennant - it's a fair assumption knowing as we do his love for Season 18, but we can't be absolutely certain!

[Dirk Gently]

[Ralph]

What's clear to me is Si must have been on something when he last posted - quite right too being on his hols and all - what's his favourite tipple?

[Ralph]

But I didn't add one to Pertwee/Baker, Ralph - I deducted one! You can't blindly assume everyone's going to add a vote to it!

My jug was half full

[Antony Cox]

I'm just rather strangely looking forward to you having to vote against at least some Pertwee stories when the next 'Doctor' round comes along....

[Jon Masters]

I'm confused by the whole thread - surely the answer is Jacobi to Simm, and the second to last regeneration standing would be Eccleston to Tennant

All the rest were lying down, you see.

(hey, its better than marking books)

[Paul Clement]

Hartnell to Troughton - 6
Pertwee to T Baker - 6
T Baker to Davison - 8
Davison to C Baker - 8
McCoy to McGann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 6
Jacobi to Simm - 1

[Antony Cox]

Hartnell to Troughton - 6
Pertwee to T Baker - 6
T Baker to Davison - 8
Davison to C Baker - 8
McCoy to McGann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 6
Jacobi to Simm - 0

[Ralph]

Hartnell to Troughton - 6
Pertwee to T Baker - 7
T Baker to Davison - 8
Davison to C Baker - 8
McCoy to McGann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 6

[Dirk Gently]

Are we all sorted now!? Yes? Good!

Hartnell to Troughton - 7
Pertwee to T Baker - 7
T Baker to Davison - 8
Davison to C Baker - 8
McCoy to McGann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 6

[Larry]

Hartnell to Troughton - 7
Pertwee to T Baker - 7
T Baker to Davison - 8
Davison to C Baker - 9
McCoy to McGann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 6

[Ian Lethbridge-Stewart]

Hartnell to Troughton - 7
Pertwee to T Baker - 7
T Baker to Davison - 8
Davison to C Baker - 10
McCoy to McGann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 6

[Paul Clement]

Hartnell to Troughton - 7
Pertwee to T Baker - 7
T Baker to Davison - 8
Davison to C Baker - 10
McCoy to McGann - 4
Eccleston to Tennent - 6

[Antony Cox]

Hartnell to Troughton - 7
Pertwee to T Baker - 6
T Baker to Davison - 8
Davison to C Baker - 10
McCoy to McGann - 4
Eccleston to Tennent - 6

[Dirk Gently]

Hartnell to Troughton - 8
Pertwee to T Baker - 6
T Baker to Davison - 8
Davison to C Baker - 10
McCoy to McGann - 4
Eccleston to Tennent - 6

[Pip Madeley]

Hartnell to Troughton - 8
Pertwee to T Baker - 5
T Baker to Davison - 8
Davison to C Baker - 10
McCoy to McGann - 4
Eccleston to Tennent - 6

[Ralph]

Hartnell to Troughton - 8
Pertwee to T Baker - 6
T Baker to Davison - 8
Davison to C Baker - 10
McCoy to McGann - 4
Eccleston to Tennent - 6