Last Regeneration Standing (NEGATIVE VOTING!)

[Larry]

again the usual rules as there was no on screen regeneration for the 2 Doctor i've not bothered with it so have added The Masters regeneration from Utopia.

and yes negative voting will be from 20th March ( and yes I will stick to that this time)


Hartnell to Troughton - 5
Pertwee to T Baker - 5
T Baker to Davison - 5
Davison to c Baker - 5
C Baker - Mccoy - 5
Mccoy to Mcgann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 5

[Antony Cox]

Hartnell to Troughton - 5
Pertwee to T Baker - 5
T Baker to Davison - 5
Davison to c Baker - 6
C Baker - Mccoy - 5
Mccoy to Mcgann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 5

Deffo the most visually appealing for me, and a good dramatic climax (we all like those )

[WhiteCrow]

No - has it come to this?

[Paul Clement]

Hartnell to Troughton - 5
Pertwee to T Baker - 5
T Baker to Davison - 5
Davison to c Baker - 6
C Baker - Mccoy - 4
Mccoy to Mcgann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 5

[WhiteCrow]

Sorry - but this thread has now been fixed for accuracy ...

Hartnell to Troughton - 5
Pertwee to T Baker - 5
T Baker to Davison - 5
Davison to c Baker - 6
McCoy-in-a-wig - McCoy-without - 3
Mccoy to Mcgann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 5[

[Pip Madeley]

Billy to Pat - 5
Johnny P to Tommy B - 4
Tommy B to Pete D - 5
Pete D to Col B - 6
Col B to McSylv - 3
McSylv to McPaul - 5
Ecclescakes to Ten-Inch - 5
Derek Hamobi to Sam Tyler - 5

[Dirk Gently]

Hartnell to Troughton - 5
Pertwee to T Baker - 5
T Baker to Davison - 5
Davison to c Baker - 6
C Baker - Mccoy - 3
Mccoy to Mcgann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 5

[Ralph]

Hartnell to Troughton - 5
Pertwee to T Baker - 6
T Baker to Davison - 5
Davison to c Baker - 6
C Baker - Mccoy - 3
Mccoy to Mcgann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 5

[Zbigniev Hamson]

Hartnell to Troughton - 5
Pertwee to T Baker - 6
T Baker to Davison - 5
Davison to c Baker - 6
C Baker - Mccoy - 3
Mccoy to Mcgann - 4
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 5


Great to see the then-popular morphng at the time, but in hindsight it's just gurning and crap.

[Pip Madeley]

Hartnell to Troughton - 5
Pertwee to T Baker - 5
T Baker to Davison - 5
Davison to c Baker - 6
C Baker - Mccoy - 3
Mccoy to Mcgann - 4
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 5

A simple (and mis-lined) vision mix without any effects - how dull.

[Paul Clement]

Hartnell to Troughton - 5
Pertwee to T Baker - 5
T Baker to Davison - 5
Davison to c Baker - 6
C Baker - Mccoy - 2
Mccoy to Mcgann - 4
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 5

[Antony Cox]

Hartnell to Troughton - 5
Pertwee to T Baker - 5
T Baker to Davison - 5
Davison to c Baker - 6
C Baker - Mccoy - 1
Mccoy to Mcgann - 4
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 5

[Larry]

Hartnell to Troughton - 5
Pertwee to T Baker - 5
T Baker to Davison - 5
Davison to c Baker - 6
C Baker - Mccoy - 1
Mccoy to Mcgann - 4
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 6

[MacNimon]

I didn't think this one would last long...

Hartnell to Troughton - 5
Pertwee to T Baker - 5
T Baker to Davison - 5
Davison to c Baker - 6
C Baker - Mccoy - 0
Mccoy to Mcgann - 4
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 6

[Ralph]

A simple (and mis-lined) vision mix without any effects - how dull.

We're judging it on special effects?....hmmm I assumed it wasn't as superficial as that but the atmosphere and context of the event - another bollocks mindless Last standing thread...

[Pip Madeley]

Bloody Pertwee agenda.

[Ralph]

Bloody superficial effects CGI-esque agenda

[Pip Madeley]

Bloody superficial effects CGI-esque agenda

Who said anything about superficial CGI effects? I'd prefer something like this myself.

[Zbigniev Hamson]

Isn't that just a superficial CGI effect though?

[Pip Madeley]

I should've added overstated to my post.

[Dirk Gently]

Hartnell to Troughton - 5
Pertwee to T Baker - 5
T Baker to Davison - 5
Davison to c Baker - 6
McCoy to McGann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 6

I like it! Although I prefer the Troughton to Pertwee one.

[Antony Cox]

I prefer the Troughton to Pertwee one.

A quick look on Youtube will find you a real (fan-made) Trout/Pert regeneration.

[Dirk Gently]

Two of them, a flash & it's over one & a TARDIS demat one that goes on for nearly a minute.

[Antony Cox]

Well I didn't say they were perfect!

[Paul Clement]

Hartnell to Troughton - 5
Pertwee to T Baker - 5
T Baker to Davison - 5
Davison to c Baker - 6
McCoy to McGann - 5
Eccleston to Tennent - 5
Jacobi to Simm - 5