The Official Vortex Results thread

[MacNimon]

The official results for Seasons 1 & 2 are as follows:


Season 1


The Aztecs 8.46
The Daleks 8.19
An Unearthly Child 7.69
Marco Polo 7.61
The Keys of Marinus 6.33
The Edge of Destruction 5.83
The Sensorites 5.77
The Reign of Terror 5.66


The average score for Season 1 is 6.94



Season 2

The Time Meddler 7.62
The Dalek Invasion of Earth 7.57
The Crusade 7.35
The Romans 6.92
The Rescue 6.75
The Chase 6.3
Planet of Giants 6.27
The Web Planet 5.4
The Space Museum 5.29

The average score for Season 2 is 6.61

The best-rated Season 1 stories have proved much more popular overall than the best-rated Season 2 stories, with the top 4 all being from S1, followed by 5 from S2. The Aztecs are now at number one, closely followed by The Daleks,, while The Space Museum is propping up the table.
Overall, we have...

1.The Aztecs 8.46
2.The Daleks 8.19
3.An Unearthly Child 7.69
4.The Time Meddler 7.62
5.Marco Polo 7.61
6.The Dalek Invasion of Earth 7.57
7.The Crusade 7.35
8.The Romans 6.92
9.The Rescue 6.75
10.The Keys of Marinus 6.33
11.The Chase 6.3
12.Planet of Giants 6.27
13.The Edge of Destruction 5.83
14.The Sensorites 5.77
15.The Reign of Terror 5.66
16.The Web Planet 5.4
17.The Space Museum 5.29


As for season openers, An Unearthly Child is well in front of Planet Of Giants.

And as for Dalek stories, so far it's...

1.The Daleks 8.19
2.The Dalek Invasion of Earth 7.57
3.The Chase 6.3

Overall so far, the series has an average rating of 6.79

[Jonno]

S2 is closer to S1 than I would have imagined, especially given that half of S1rates higher than anything from S2! Makes for interesting reading though - I like stats, me!

[Larry]

think s2 results are pretty much as expected and i'm glad to see The Time Meddler doing so well..

[SiHart]

I'm pleased to see Edge of Destruction slip down the season 1 table!

Si xx

[Anthony Williams]

might be a stupid question, but shouldn't DIOE and The Time Meddler be the other way around on the scores list, as The Time Meddler got a higher score?

Ant x

[Larry]

I'm pleased to see Edge of Destruction slip down the season 1 table!

Si xx

well I beg to differ on that one..

[Wayne]

More or less what i expected for S2.
As for the 2 seasons together; Shame to see twee rubbish like The Romans, & downright dull mediocrity like 'Reign of Terror' beat decent (if not awesome) stories like Edge of Destruction, Planet of Giants, & even Web Planet.
And DIOE is way overated.

[MacNimon]

might be a stupid question, but shouldn't DIOE and The Time Meddler be the other way around on the scores list, as The Time Meddler got a higher score?

Ant x

Oops! That was just a slip, I'd fix it but my edit button for that post seems to have disappeared at the moment...I'll adjust it for Fridays results.

[Larry]

never noticed that but yippee Time Medller is even higher up the table..

[Paul Clement]

And DIOE is way overated.

As is Daleks

[MacNimon]

Thanks for adjusting that, Si. But there was one other slight adjustment needed (which no-one else seemed to notice!), if you look closely...and so The Time Meddler actually moves up another position...

I'll not rush as much this week, I'll be a bit more careful when I'm posting the results....I promise!!!!

1.The Aztecs 8.46
2.The Daleks 8.19
3.An Unearthly Child 7.69
4.The Time Meddler 7.62
5.Marco Polo 7.61
6.The Dalek Invasion of Earth 7.57
7.The Crusade 7.35
8.The Romans 6.92
9.The Rescue 6.75
10.The Keys of Marinus 6.33
11.The Chase 6.3
12.Planet of Giants 6.27
13.The Edge of Destruction 5.83
14.The Sensorites 5.77
15.The Reign of Terror 5.66
16.The Web Planet 5.4
17.The Space Museum 5.29

[Paul Clement]

Aztecs topping the table gives me a warm glow inside.

[Larry]

Aztecs topping the table gives me a warm glow inside.

it's a good story - but better than The Daleks, not sure about that one..

[Paul Clement]

it's a good story - but better than The Daleks, not sure about that one..

Personally, I'm certain that it is. I'd rate it as the second best Hartnell story after DIOE.

[Pip Madeley]

You can now find Kenny's In The Vortex project on the PS website:

http://planetskaro.org.uk/creative/reviews/vortex.php

A permanent home for all the results.

[Milky Tears]

An Unearthly Child is still too high.

[MacNimon]

The results for Season 3:

The Daleks' Master Plan 8.53
The War Machines 8.24
The Massacre 7.97
Mission to the Unknown 7.12
The Ark 6.39
The Myth Makers 6.36
The Savages 6.31
The Gunfighters 6.16
Galaxy 4 5.73
The Celestial Toymaker 4.00

The season average for season 3 is 6.69

Which means that we have a new story in both the top and bottom slots, The Daleks Master Plan at number 1, and The Celestial Toymaker coming in last at the moment. Here's the complete list to date:




1.The Daleks' Master Plan 8.53
2.The Aztecs 8.46
3.The War Machines 8.24
4.The Daleks 8.19
5.The Massacre 7.97
6.An Unearthly Child 7.69
7.The Time Meddler 7.62
8.Marco Polo 7.61
9.The Dalek Invasion of Earth 7.57
10.The Crusade 7.35
11.Mission to the Unknown 7.12
12.The Romans 6.92
13.The Rescue 6.75
14.The Ark 6.39
15.The Myth Makers 6.36
16.The Keys of Marinus 6.33
17.The Savages 6.31
18.The Chase 6.3
19.Planet of Giants 6.27
20.The Gunfighters 6.16
21.The Edge of Destruction 5.83
22.The Sensorites 5.77
23.Galaxy 4 5.73
24.The Reign of Terror 5.66
25.The Web Planet 5.4
26.The Space Museum 5.29
27.The Celestial Toymaker 4.00

Season openers:

1.An Unearthly Child 7.69
2.Planet of Giants 6.27
3.Galaxy 4 5.73


And as for Dalek stories, so far it's...

1.The Daleks' Master Plan 8.53
2.The Daleks 8.19
3.The Dalek Invasion of Earth 7.57
4.Mission to the Unknown 7.12
5.The Chase 6.3

Overall so far, the series has an average rating of 6.76

[Larry]

considering there's so much of this season is missing I'm supprised to see most of the stories doing so well in the over all standings. I know people will be basing their votes on the audios but i'd of still thought those stories that still exist would of on average scored higher marks..

[Perry Vale]

An Unearthly Child is still too high.

The War Machines is way too high.

[Pip Madeley]

I never got to add my ratings for Myth/Massacre/Savages, so I'll do so when it comes to putting the results on PS.

[MacNimon]

I never got to add my ratings for Myth/Massacre/Savages, so I'll do so when it comes to putting the results on PS.

Oops! Sorry, Pip...I forgot you were coming back to a few stories. Just post your ratings if you want, and I'll adjust the scores accordingly.

[brandynigma]

Oops! Sorry, Pip...I forgot you were coming back to a few stories. Just post your ratings if you want, and I'll adjust the scores accordingly.

Would you mind if I did that as well? Been so busy with work lately, I didn't have time to review these...

Galaxy 4 - 7/10
Mission to the Unknown - 8/10
The Myth Makers - 6/10
The Daleks' Master Plan - 9/10
The Massacre - 10/10
The Ark - 8/10
The Celestial Toymaker - 9/10
The Gunfighters - 6/10
The Savages - No rating (not heard it)
The War Machines - 9/10

[Pip Madeley]

Myth Makers - 3/10
Massacre - 7/10
Savages - 6/10

Ta

[MacNimon]

Just waiting on Ralph now...

[MacNimon]

Once again, we have yet another story taking over top position in the table, but The Celestial Toymaker remains rooted to the bottom for the moment. Also, there were a few additional scores for Season 3 which resulted in a few mid-table changes.

Results for Season 4...

The Power of the Daleks 8.74
The Evil of the Daleks 8.37
The Moonbase 7.67
The Faceless Ones 7.26
The Macra Terror 6.97
The Tenth Planet 6.69
The Underwater Menace 6.11
The Smugglers 6.05
The Highlanders 5.16

Season 4 average 7.00


Amended results for Season 3...

The Daleks' Master Plan 8.55
The War Machines 8.28
The Massacre 8.03
Mission to the Unknown 7.17
The Savages 6.57
The Ark 6.48
The Gunfighters 6.15
The Myth Makers 6.13
Galaxy 4 5.81
The Celestial Toymaker 4.26



Overall.


1.The Power of the Daleks 8.74
2.The Daleks' Master Plan 8.55
3.The Aztecs 8.46
4.The Evil of the Daleks 8.37
5.The War Machines 8.28
6.The Daleks 8.19
7.The Massacre 8.03
8.An Unearthly Child 7.69
9.The Moonbase 7.67
10.The Time Meddler 7.62
11.Marco Polo 7.61
12.The Dalek Invasion of Earth 7.57
13.The Crusade 7.35
14.The Faceless Ones 7.26
15.Mission to the Unknown 7.17
16.The Macra Terror 6.97
17.The Romans 6.92
18.The Rescue 6.75
19.The Tenth Planet 6.69
20.The Savages 6.57

21.The Ark 6.48
22.The Keys of Marinus 6.33
23.The Chase 6.3
24.Planet of Giants 6.27
25.The Gunfighters 6.15
26.The Myth Makers 6.13
27.The Underwater Menace 6.11
28.The Smugglers 6.05
29.The Edge of Destruction 5.83
30.Galaxy 4 5.81
31.The Sensorites 5.77
32.The Reign of Terror 5.66
33.The Web Planet 5.4
34.The Space Museum 5.29
35.The Highlanders 5.16
36.The Celestial Toymaker 4.26

Overall series average 6.60


Season openers:

1.An Unearthly Child 7.69
2.Planet of Giants 6.27
3.The Smugglers 6.05
4.Galaxy 4 5.73


Doctors debuts

1.Second Doctor8.74
2.First Doctor7.69



The Daleks

1.The Power of the Daleks 8.74
2.The Daleks' Master Plan 8.55
3.The Evil of the Daleks 8.37
4.The Daleks 8.19
5.The Dalek Invasion of Earth 7.57
6.Mission to the Unknown 7.17
7.The Chase 6.3



The Cybermen...

1.The Moonbase 7.67
2.The Tenth Planet 6.69