PDA Cover Competition Group 6

[Paul Clement]

The Sixth Group begins, with three new covers for you to choose from. But which one will get your vote? Will it be Heart of Tardis, Grave Matter or Asylum?

[Paul Clement]

I going to have to give this a good think.

[Paul Clement]

This was quite a tough choice.

I like the background to Grave Matter, but the Doctor and Peri have so obviously been pasted onto the image, and it stands out too much.
Although both Pat and Tom's likenesses adorn Heart of Tardis, there's nothing else to recommend it.
Asylum on the other hand is a very simple but quite effective image, though it lacks any visual Doctor Who reference which I usually prefer covers to have.

In the end, the story I plumped for was Asylum as it's faults were minor compared with that of the other two.

[Larry]

it's very hard to find any thing positive to say about Heart of the TARDIS, it is IMO not only one of the worst PDA's ever written but one of the worst books in the entire NA, MA. PDA & EDA range. How ever it's one positive is the cover it's colourfull which makes it pleasing on the eye and it has Tom and Pat on the cover so my vote gose for Heart of the TARDIS.

[Andrew Curnow]

I've never read the book, but I do agree with Larry about the cover, so Heart of TARDIS gets my vote. Asylum fails on my 'nothing Who-y' on the cover criteria, pretty though it may be, and Grave Matter is OK, but the pics of the regulars are rather dull.

[Stuart Wallis]

Heart Of TARDIS has the most intriguing cover, though whether the contents match its standards...

[Pip Madeley]

Anything with my two favourite Doctors on the cover, gets my vote.

[Lord President]

Anything with my two favourite Doctors on the cover, gets my vote.

Tom Baker getting to appear with any other Doctor would get my vote any day of the week!

[Dave Tudor]

Well I was tempted to go for 'Heart Of TARDIS' for pretty much the same reasons as everyone else, but 'Asylum' is the cover that really stands out for me here.