Rate Torchwood

**Paul Clement** · 4th Dec 2006, 1:12 PM

I know what you mean, Ghost Machine is third bottom in my list, but I really enjoyed it. It just shows how good this first season of Torchwood has been.

**Rob McCow** · 4th Dec 2006, 2:21 PM

I haven't been that impressed by Torchwood. And the more I think about Cyberwoman in paticular the more I think it was absolutely terrible, if quite exciting. In paticular, the Cyberwoman outfit was an utterly tacky disaster.

The show works better without the CGI monsters too, as the recent episode shows.

**Milky Tears** · 4th Dec 2006, 2:25 PM

Torchwood sucks like a Doctor Who fan in a convention hotel room.

Pray
Back For Good
Why Can't I Wake Up With You
I Found Heaven
Everything Changes
Could It Be Magic
Babe
Relight My Fire

**Larry** · 4th Dec 2006, 4:55 PM

They Keep Killing Suzie
Cyberwoman
countrcide
Every Thing Changes
Small Worlds
The Ghost Machine
Day One
Greeks Baring Gifts.

**Andrew Curnow** · 4th Dec 2006, 5:41 PM

They Keep Killing Suzie
Ghost Machine
Small Worlds
Greeks Bearing Gifts
Everything Changes
Cyberwoman
Countrycide
Day One

**Doctor Vendetta** · 4th Dec 2006, 7:33 PM

They Keep Killing Suzie
Countrycide
Small Worlds
Ghost Machine
Greeks Bearing Gifts
Everything Changes
Cyberwoman
Day One

**Perry Vale** · 5th Dec 2006, 9:28 AM

Small Worlds 9.5/10
Ghost Machine 8/10
Everything Changes 7.5/10
Day One 7/10
They Keep Killing Susie 7/10
Greeks Bearing Gifts 6/10
Countrycide 5/10
Cyberwoman 5/10

Wayne · 7th Dec 2006, 2:40 PM

Cyberwoman
Countrycide
Greeks Bearing Gifts
They Keep Killing Suzie
Ghost Machine
Small Worlds
Everything Changes
Day One

It's getting harder! Very little between the first 4 eps.

If only S2 of new Who was up to this standard.

Dave Lewis · 7th Dec 2006, 5:25 PM

Originally Posted by Wayne

If only S2 of new Who was up to this standard.

If only seasons one to twenty six of Doctor Who were up to this standard...

Dave Lewis · 7th Dec 2006, 5:46 PM

1.They Keep Killing Suzie
"Simply stunning - by far the best episode of the series, and if they can top this in the last four episodes, then there's some absolutely unbelievable episodes to come."

2.Ghost Machine
"I didn't find it tried to cram too much in, nor did I feel (as others have) that there was any filler. It's a perfect size."

3.Countrycide
"I'd give 'Countrycide' eight bags of human flesh out of ten."

4.Greeks Bearing Gifts
"'Greeks Bearing Gifts' was very disjointed but I liked it - not a lot, but I liked it. It was the funniest episode yet, it had the sexiest guest star yet, and Jack was even more like the Doctor than ever."

5.Day One
"Much as I enjoyed seeing the formation of the Torchwood team in 'Everything Changes', it was more fun to see them actually working as a unit and investigating a real Torchwood-esque case."

6.Cyberwoman
"If Pip cringed at the snog, or Owen's stiffy, I cringed every time GDL moaned 'I'm soooooooorrrrrrrry' or started weeping again."

7.Everything Changes
"The swearing was a f***ing disgrace."

8.Small Worlds
"Barrowman aside, this was really rather dreadful. Can I say... shall I... yes - I'll make my mind up and say that this was the weakest episode yet."

By the way, after re-reading my 'Cyberwoman' review, I spotted this rather less-than-brilliant prediction of what was to come...

...despite his pleas about her not resisting the kiss, Owen has less chance than me with Gwen, because of her infatuation with the ever-wonderful (but now grittier and darker) Cap'n Jack.

Wayne · 7th Dec 2006, 6:49 PM

Originally Posted by Dave Lewis

If only seasons one to twenty six of Doctor Who were up to this standard...

@Dave
Yeah, but the classic series finished nearly 20yrs ago. TV is so different in the 21st century.

On many levels the two are bit incomparable, IMO.

Wayne · 10th Dec 2006, 11:53 PM

Cyberwoman
Countrycide
Greeks Bearing Gifts
They Keep Killing Suzie
Ghost Machine
Small Worlds
Everything Changes
Day One
Invisible Eugene

**Milky Tears** · 11th Dec 2006, 12:04 AM

Pray
Back For Good
Why Can't I Wake Up With You
I Found Heaven
Everything Changes
Never Forget
Could It Be Magic
Babe
Relight My Fire

**Larry** · 11th Dec 2006, 5:38 PM

They Keep Killing Suzie
Cyberwoman
countrcide
Every Thing Changes
Small Worlds
The Ghost Machine
Day One
Greeks Baring Gifts.
Random Shoes

**Perry Vale** · 13th Dec 2006, 12:45 AM

Small Worlds 9.5/10
Ghost Machine 8/10
Random Shoes 8/10
Everything Changes 7.5/10
Day One 7/10
They Keep Killing Susie 7/10
Greeks Bearing Gifts 6/10
Countrycide 5/10
Cyberwoman 5/10

**Anthony Williams** · 15th Dec 2006, 9:21 AM

Small Worlds
Countrycide
They Keep Killing Suzie
The Ghost Machine
Greeks Bearing Gifts
Cyberwoman
Everything Changers
Day One
Random Shoes

Ant x

**Paul Clement** · 16th Dec 2006, 5:35 PM

Small Worlds
Countrycide
They Keep Killing Suzie
Random Shoes
Greeks Bearing Gifts
Cyberwoman
Ghost Machine
Day One
Everything Changes

Wayne · 18th Dec 2006, 12:49 PM

Cyberwoman
Countrycide
Greeks Bearing Gifts
They Keep Killing Suzie
Ghost Machine
Small Worlds
Everything Changes
Out of Time
Day One
Invisible Eugene/Ramdom Shoes/Whatever!

**Larry** · 18th Dec 2006, 4:31 PM

They Keep Killing Suzie
out of Time
Cyberwoman
countrcide
Every Thing Changes
Small Worlds
The Ghost Machine
Day One
Greeks Baring Gifts.
Random Shoes

**Andrew Curnow** · 18th Dec 2006, 6:55 PM

They Keep Killing Suzie
Ghost Machine
Small Worlds
Greeks Bearing Gifts
Last Night's episode (would have scored lower if Gwen's sex-talk hadn't been so entertaining!)
Everything Changes
Random Shoes
Cyberwoman
Countrycide
Day One

**Paul Clement** · 18th Dec 2006, 7:05 PM

Small Worlds
Countrycide
Out of Time
They Keep Killing Suzie
Random Shoes
Greeks Bearing Gifts
Cyberwoman
Ghost Machine
Day One
Everything Changes

**Perry Vale** · 19th Dec 2006, 9:16 AM

Small Worlds 9.5/10
Ghost Machine 8/10
Random Shoes 8/10
Everything Changes 7.5/10
Out Of Time 7/10
Day One 7/10
They Keep Killing Susie 7/10
Greeks Bearing Gifts 6/10
Countrycide 5/10
Cyberwoman 5/10

Dave Lewis · 20th Dec 2006, 3:08 PM

1.They Keep Killing Suzie
"Simply stunning - by far the best episode of the series."

2.Ghost Machine
"I didn't find it tried to cram too much in, nor did I feel (as others have) that there was any filler. It's a perfect size."

3.Countrycide
"I'd give 'Countrycide' eight bags of human flesh out of ten."

4.Greeks Bearing Gifts
"'Greeks Bearing Gifts' was very disjointed but I liked it - not a lot, but I liked it. It was the funniest episode yet, it had the sexiest guest star yet, and Jack was even more like the Doctor than ever."

5.Random Shoes
"There were weak points about 'Random Shoes', I have to admit, and it certainly wasn't the best episode yet... but after such a moving ending I can't find it in my heart to criticise it too much."

6.Day One
"Much as I enjoyed seeing the formation of the Torchwood team in 'Everything Changes', it was more fun to see them actually working as a unit and investigating a real Torchwood-esque case."

7.Cyberwoman
"If Pip cringed at the snog, or Owen's stiffy, I cringed every time GDL moaned 'I'm soooooooorrrrrrrry' or started weeping again."

8.Everything Changes
"The swearing was a f***ing disgrace."

9.Small Worlds
"Barrowman aside, this was really rather dreadful. Can I say... shall I... yes - I'll make my mind up and say that this was the weakest episode yet."

**Anthony Williams** · 24th Dec 2006, 11:51 PM

Small Worlds
Countrycide
Combat
Out of Time
They Keep Killing Suzie
The Ghost Machine
Greeks Bearing Gifts
Cyberwoman
Everything Changers
Day One
Random Shoes

Ant x

**Si Hunt** · 25th Dec 2006, 8:39 AM

I can't remember half the titles now, let alone rank them! I've loved them all, but I couldn't put an order on them til I've seen them again on DVD.

Si.

Thread: Rate Torchwood

Thread Tools

Display

Similar Threads

Will Torchwood return?

So Where Were Torchwood?

Torchwood America

Torchwood on DVD

RATE Torchwood: Series 2!

PSAudios 6.1. Bless You Doctor Who