STAR TREK - Season 1 Survivor!

[Wayne]

You can never have too many games!

You know the drill. Negative voting only begins in two weeks. And yes, I'm going through every series, (except for the Animated Series) with a few special rounds to determine the best story of each series; each of which will then go on to a grand finale leaving just one final Star Trek episode standing. Any up for this, or will interest die when get to Voyager and Enterprise?
So....

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 10
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 10
Balance of Terror 10
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 10
The Conscience of the King 10
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 10
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 10
The Return of the Archons 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[Wayne]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 10
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 10
Balance of Terror 10
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 10
The Conscience of the King 10
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 10
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 10
The Return of the Archons 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 11
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[SiHart]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 10
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 10
Balance of Terror 10
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 10
The Conscience of the King 10
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 10
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 10
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 11
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
Operation: Annihilate! 10

I've added a point to Return of the Archons. It is the will of Landrew.

[Wayne]

Good choice as it'll soon be Red Hour.
And sorry for being a compulsive pedant, but it's Landru.

[Philipnet]

Oh, this could be fun:

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 10
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 10
Balance of Terror 10
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 10
The Conscience of the King 10
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 10
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 10
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 11
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 11
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[SiHart]

I thought it was Landru but let my doubts get the better of me!

[MacNimon]

This'll be good...the only problem is what to choose first!

My first point goes to an old childhood favourite of mine which never quite reached the 'classic' status of many other episodes...

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 10
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 10
Balance of Terror 10
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 10
The Conscience of the King 10
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 10
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 11
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 11
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[Andrew Curnow]

This should be fun. To be fair, I would be lying if I said I knew exactly which episode was which in all of the Trek series, but I daresay I can look them up on this thing called the in-ter-net that everybody seems to be waffling on about nowadays. I think I'm OK with season 1 though so...

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 10
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 10
Balance of Terror 10
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 10
The Conscience of the King 11
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 10
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 11
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 11
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[MacNimon]

I've got to admit that I'll enjoy this...for a while. Like Wayne suggests though, I'll fall away during Voyager and Enterprise...I simply haven't seen much of either of them. I'll maybe try to make the effort though before we reach those, or else just concentrate on the handful of episode which I am familiar with!

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 10
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 10
Balance of Terror 10
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 10
The Conscience of the King 11
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 11
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 11
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 11
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[Paul Clement]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 10
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 10
Balance of Terror 10
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 10
The Conscience of the King 11
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 11
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 11
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 12
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[SiHart]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 10
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 10
Balance of Terror 11
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 10
The Conscience of the King 11
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 11
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 11
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 12
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[Wayne]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 11
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 10
Balance of Terror 11
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 10
The Conscience of the King 11
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 11
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 11
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 12
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[Rob McCow]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 11
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 10
Balance of Terror 11
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 11
The Conscience of the King 11
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 11
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 11
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 12
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[Jon Masters]

I feel I'm not geeky enough to know what to vote for

[Philipnet]

@Jon - shh

That doesn't mean you can't play - you'll just be a curve ball in the game ;-)

[Andrew Curnow]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 11
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 10
Balance of Terror 11
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 11
The Conscience of the King 11
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 11
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 12
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 12
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[Wayne]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 11
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 10
Balance of Terror 12
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 11
The Conscience of the King 11
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 11
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 12
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 12
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[Paul Clement]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 9
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 11
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 10
Balance of Terror 12
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 11
The Conscience of the King 11
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 11
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 12
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 12
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[SiHart]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 9
The Corbomite Maneuver 11
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 11
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 10
Balance of Terror 12
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 11
The Conscience of the King 11
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 11
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 12
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 12
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[Andrew Curnow]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 9
The Corbomite Maneuver 11
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 11
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 11
Balance of Terror 12
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 11
The Conscience of the King 11
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 11
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 12
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 12
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[Dirk Gently]

I'll not be able to play as I know less about Star Trek series than Doctor Who, and that's saying something.

I was looking at the list and thinking "I don't recognise any of these titles other than The Corbomite Maneuver & Mudd's Women". And I can't remember if they're anygood.

[Wayne]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 9
The Corbomite Maneuver 11
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 11
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 11
Balance of Terror 12
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 11
The Conscience of the King 11
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 12
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 10
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 12
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 12
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[Paul Clement]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 9
The Corbomite Maneuver 11
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 11
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 11
Balance of Terror 12
What are Little Girls Made of? 10
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 11
The Conscience of the King 11
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 12
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 9
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 12
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 12
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[SiHart]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 9
The Corbomite Maneuver 11
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 11
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 11
Balance of Terror 12
What are Little Girls Made of? 9
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 11
The Conscience of the King 11
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 12
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 9
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 12
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 12
Operation: Annihilate! 10

[Andrew Curnow]

I'll not be able to play as I know less about Star Trek series than Doctor Who, and that's saying something.

I was looking at the list and thinking "I don't recognise any of these titles other than The Corbomite Maneuver & Mudd's Women". And I can't remember if they're anygood

I don't know them all intimately Tim, but I'm continuing my normal tack of not letting the facts get in the way of having an ill-formed opinion. Although, having said that, once I'd done a little 'digging' I found that I recognised more of them than I expected - Conscience of a King, for example, is the 'war criminal posing as an actor' one; and Space Seed is the one with Khan (pre-Wrath!)

So anyway, today's hastily-constructed decision is...

Where No Man Has Gone Before 9
The Corbomite Maneuver 11
Mudd's Women 10
The Enemy Within 11
The Man Trap 10
The Naked Time 10
Charlie X 11
Balance of Terror 12
What are Little Girls Made of? 9
Dagger of the Mind 10
Miri 11
The Conscience of the King 12
The Galileo Seven 10
Court Martial 10
The Menagerie 12
Shore Leave 10
The Squire of Gothos 10
Arena 10
The Alternative Factor 10
Tomorrow is Yesterday 11
The Return of the Archons 11
A Taste of Armageddon 10
Space Seed 9
This Side of Paradise 10
The Devil in the Dark 12
Errand of Mercy 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 12
Operation: Annihilate! 10