Lecture Time

[Rob McCow]

Powerpoint is a killer of minds and souls - as has been confirmed by a recent study.

Anyone who's been a victim of "death by Powerpoint" - that glazed and distant feeling that overwhelms you when some sales droid starts their presentation - will be reassured by Aussie researchers who've discovered biological reasons for the feeling.

Humans just don't like absorbing information verbally and visually at the same time - one or the other is fine but not both simultaneously.

Researchers at the University of New South Wales in Australia found the brain is limited in the amount of information it can absorb - and presenting the same information in visual and verbal form - like reading from a typical Powerpoint slide - overloads this part of memory and makes absorbing information more difficult.

Professor Sweller said: "The use of the PowerPoint presentation has been a disaster. It should be ditched.

"It is effective to speak to a diagram, because it presents information in a different form. But it is not effective to speak the same words that are written, because it is putting too much load on the mind and decreases your ability to understand what is being presented."

The theory of "cognitive load theory" suggest the memory can deal with two or three tasks for a period of a few seconds - any more than that and information starts to get lost.

There's more from the Sydney Morning Herald here, or there's an abstract of Sweller's work (pdf) here.

Professor John Sweller is not the first to question the overarching power of Powerpoint. Edward Tufte is a professor emeritus at Yale and an information and interface design expert. His 2003 book The Cognitive Style of Powerpoint: Pitching Out Corrupts Within makes similar claims.

Of course, the laws of irony state that the results of this study must have been given in a powerpoint presentation

Do you find this is the case? I am paticularly bad at taking in information in lectures. I would have done far better at Uni if we'd have been given the notes at the start of the lesson and told to get on with it. Can you cope with the curse of Powerpoint?

[Martin Penny]

Of course, the laws of irony state that the results of this study must have been given in a powerpoint presentation

I'd rather just get notes to be honest, Powerpoint looks all flashy, and it's okay now and then. But I get fed up of seeing some vague notes jotted down on a presentation every week, as I tend to forget everything once I leave the room anyway.

Having said that, I myself am using Powerpoint to make a presentation next week

[Ralph]

The worst of these presentations is when they go beyond 20 minutes plus sitting on uncomfortable chairs plus presenters who bore the arse off you of which I have known a few

[Pip Madeley]

The last Powerpoint presentation I made was in 2005.

I ended the presentation arguing with one of the class over whether Steve Coogan was born in Middleton (say I) or Rochdale (say she). I said Middleton! And Middleton's in Rochdale. So we were both right, but I was more specific. Middleton's just down the road from me.

What were we talking about?